The Best Baby Food Maker Review

The Babycook scored below average for ease of use with 4 product earning higher scores for this metric.
Providing the highest quality natural foods for baby's first foods is a priority for many parents. Finding the best baby food maker can be a challenge when you know nothing about making baby food. That's where we can help! We purchased and tested the six of the top baby food makers on the market to discover which options make the best purees. We ran each maker through a gamut of tests with a variety of foods to pinpoint the right product for different goals and families. From the all-in-one steamer/blender to the simple immersion blender, we did the messy work so you don't have to.

Read the full review below >

Test Results and Ratings

Displaying 1 - 5 of 6 << Previous | View All | Next >>

Analysis and Award Winners


Review by:
Juliet Spurrier, MD & Wendy Schmitz

Last Updated:
Friday
May 19, 2017

Share:

Best baby food maker


Baby Bullet


Editors' Choice Award

$59.98
at Amazon
See It

Quality purees
Easy to use and clean
Inexpensive
Doesn't cook

The Baby Bullet is a quick and simple baby food making solution with few parts that is easy to clean. The Bullet creates smooth purees and chunkier foods by blending or pulsing as desired. It has few parts to keep track of and everything is easy to clean with no nooks or crannies for harmful bacteria or mold to hide. We like the friendly price and food storage containers that make this an affordable and useful option for most families. While you do need to cook the food on your stove top before blending, we think steaming on the stove top is just as easy as an all-in-one steam without the plastic related health concerns and a quicker dishwasher safe clean up. Unless you have your heart set on an all-in-one option you can set and forget, we think it is hard to go wrong with the impressive Baby Bullet and its simple setup.

Read full review: Baby Bullet

Easy handheld option


Sage Spoonfuls Puree and Blend


The Sage Spoonfuls Puree and Blend is a blender only product that created smooth purees for almost every food we tested and can easily be used for food preparation outside of baby food. Editors' Choice Award

$26.97
(33% off)
at Amazon
See It

Smooth purees
Versatile uses
Budget-friendly
No cooking feature

The Sage Spoonfuls Puree and Blend produced near perfect puree every time with a simple, intuitive interface that can be used quickly right out of the box. We did run into a few hiccoughs with some crunchier than desired carrots while using the immersion blender, but overall its compact size, versatility, ease of use, simple cleaning procedure, and the high-quality puree impressed us. The immersion blender enables parents to puree softer foods to a perfect consistency in a matter of seconds. We found the food processor to be equally effective, quickly grinding brown rice or oatmeal to tiny granules, perfect for baby cereals. While the immersion blender is not equipped to handle hard, raw foods, the food processor takes over in this category to finish the job. In short, this product blends like a dream, has a small footprint in your kitchen, and will definitely remain a useful cooking tool well beyond the time you use it for preparing food for your baby. With a budget-friendly price, it is hard to find fault with this healthy option.

Read full review: Sage Spoonfuls Puree and Blend

Best all-in-one steamer and blender


Cuisinart BFM-1000


Top Pick Award

$110.92
(15% off)
at Amazon
See It

Steams and blends
No food transfer
Smoother purees
Hard to clean water tank
Plastic components
Higher Price

The Cuisinart BFM-1000 is the highest ranking all-in-one we tested with a simple cooking feature and smoother purees and the other steam and blend options. The Cuisinart is an easy to use steam and cook product that utilizes the same bowl for cooking and blending making it a quicker and easier to use choice than the products that require food transfer. We liked the simple user interface and the ability to do other things while the food cooked. On the downside the Cuisinart has a hard to clean steam tank you can't see or reach into that Amazon reviewers report can get gross over time and the price is on the high side for families on a budget. However, if the price isn't a factor and you are diligent about cleanliness and routine maintenance, then the Cuisinart might be a good choice for parents who want a set and forget option.

Read full review: Cuisinart BFM-1000

select up to 5 products
Score Product Price Our Take
86
$60
Editors' Choice Award
Super easy puree blender with minimal parts and quick clean up for busy parents
84
$40
Editors' Choice Award
Simple, inexpensive and versatile, this unit makes baby food making a snap
68
$130
Top Pick Award
Easy to use all-in-one with smooth purees and quick preparation for busy parents
55
$150
Harder to use option that requires food transfer and may hide rust or mold you can't see
53
$130
Cool concept with nice safety features but hard to use and left larger chunks in pureed food
53
$130
Nice design but the puree consistency is poor and the cleanup harder if you wait

Analysis and Test Results


For testing we considered the following criteria to be the most important when it came to evaluating how well the baby food makers work, puree quality, ease of use, ease of cleaning, and health and safety.

We tested 7 of the top baby food makers on the market so you can determine which option is right for you.
We tested 7 of the top baby food makers on the market so you can determine which option is right for you.

Obviously, you want a product that creates high-quality purees for baby's first foods, but there are other factors to consider that impact daily use and cleanup. The following sections provide details on the results for the baby food makers we tested.

The Baby Bullet consistently provides smooth puree for most food products.
The Baby Bullet consistently provides smooth puree for most food products.

Puree Quality


The most important component of any baby food maker is its ability to puree food smooth enough for baby. We considered how well the products pureed, whether or not there were chunks or skins left behind, and how consistent the texture was time after time. We found most of the problems with puree quality typically had to do with the blade, the bowl and blade design that sometimes caused food to move away from the chopping area, the consistency of the food (how well it was cooked and type), and the quantity being blended. Like cooking for adults, you need to be willing to adjust your recipe as you go (such as adding extra water to particularly dry foods) to achieve a quality puree for an infant. Of course, older babies that are more accustomed to eating solids will likely not mind chunkier foods, but you should always be cautious to avoid hard solid foods to prevent choking.


The puree only food makers, in general, created smoother and more consistent puree blends than the steam and blend options. We aren't sure if the products failed to cook the food enough or the blades and product design were incapable of blending as well as the blend only options, but we created much smoother food with the Baby Bullet and the Sage Spoonfuls Puree and Blend the only two products we tested without steam capabilities. The Baby Bullet earned the top score with the Sage Spoonfuls Puree and Blend and the Cuisinart BFM-1000 coming in right behind it.

Before committing to a baby food maker of any kind  it is important to determine if you really want to make baby food. There is no shame in feeding commercial baby food products. With so many organic and natural options available you can feel good feeding baby off the shelf and skipping the time and energy involved in making your own.
Before committing to a baby food maker of any kind, it is important to determine if you really want to make baby food. There is no shame in feeding commercial baby food products. With so many organic and natural options available you can feel good feeding baby off the shelf and skipping the time and energy involved in making your own.

Ease of Use


Most of the products we tested were fairly easy to use. Naturally, the number of parts corresponded with the difficulty of setup and use, but the user interface varied from one knob to no buttons to settings that required the manual to determine.

The Baby Bullet has a safety mechanism that requires the container to be locked into the base before the blade will turn.
The Baby Bullet has a safety mechanism that requires the container to be locked into the base before the blade will turn.

All of the blender only options were simple to use, had intuitive interfaces and required little effort to assemble. The all-in-one machines required more research to operate properly. We also found ourselves constantly turning to the manual to determine just how long each particular food needed to be cooked for some of these options. It would have been helpful for these companies to provide a magnet or laminated guide of steam times, so parents are not always flipping through the manuals.


Even though the blend only options will require stove top cooking of food before use we still think that is easier and less of a hassle than using the all-in-one steamers with the higher learning curve. Once again the Baby Bullet and the Sage Spoonfuls Puree and Blend earned top scores for ease of use with the Cuisinart BFM-100 right behind them. The Babymoov Nutribaby has a complicated setup process and user panel, with two different bowls for cooking and blending making it the hardest one to learn and operate.

The Cuisinart suffered in health and safety being made almost entirely of plastic components that contact baby's food. Studies indicate that even BPA-free plastic can potentially leach into food products  which gives us pause on any cooking vessel made of plastic.
The Cuisinart suffered in health and safety being made almost entirely of plastic components that contact baby's food. Studies indicate that even BPA-free plastic can potentially leach into food products, which gives us pause on any cooking vessel made of plastic.

Health and Safety


Health and safety include elements related to potential health concerns or the possibility of injury while using the machines. For the blender, only options the main concern is the blades and is there some kind of safety mechanism that prevents the blades from spinning when your fingers may be in contact with the blades.


With the steamers, we considered the potential for plastic to leach chemicals into food, especially when heated during the cooking process and whether or not the devices had steam tanks that were hard to clean or difficult to see into indicating a potential for bacteria or mold growth that could reach baby's food.

The Sage Spoonfuls has limited plastic components  and nothing cooks in plastic making it a healthier option than all-in-one options that heat baby's food in plastic.
The Sage Spoonfuls has limited plastic components, and nothing cooks in plastic making it a healthier option than all-in-one options that heat baby's food in plastic.

The blender only options once again excelled with no water tanks or nooks and crannies for things to grow unchecked. This gave the Baby Bullet and Sage Spoonfuls Puree and Blend top scores with the Cuisinart BFM-1000 earning the lowest score thanks to an impossible to see into the water tank and a plastic mixing bowl. All of the options had safety mechanisms to prevent blade interaction, but they all made different efforts to prevent burns from steaming. The all-in-one options that require transferring cooked food from one container to the blender container have the highest potential for burns, which really hurt the BEABA Babycook and the Babymoov Nutribaby.

No matter how messy the Baby Bullet becomes  it is easy to rinse clean and is dishwasher safe or hand washable.
No matter how messy the Baby Bullet becomes, it is easy to rinse clean and is dishwasher safe or hand washable.

Ease of Cleaning


Cleaning food off of any surface is difficult, particularly if it is sharp. Extra care needs to be taken when cleaning each of the products we tested. Cleaning the all-in-one products was a bit trickier, as the water chambers cannot be accessed (these need to be cleaned periodically to prevent mineral deposit build-up to preserve the longevity of the machine).


A lot of the machines had top-rack dishwasher safe parts, which was helpful, but we also found the use of a bottle brush really simplified the hand-washing process and quick rinsing after use helped as well. Even though many parts were dishwasher safe, we recommend hand washing whenever possible to prolong the longevity of the product. This will also help prevent degradation of the plastic that could lead to potential leaching of chemicals.

If you don't immediately rinse the blades on the Baby Brezza Complete  you will have difficulty cleaning it as the pureed food will dry and stick inside the holes.
If you don't immediately rinse the blades on the Baby Brezza Complete, you will have difficulty cleaning it as the pureed food will dry and stick inside the holes.

The Sage Spoonfuls Puree and Blend earned the highest score for ease of cleaning. With few parts that clean quickly and no small crevices or need for a bottle brush, it is tough to beat this blender. The Baby Bullet was right behind with only two components that also require no special parts or harbor hidden bacteria you can't reach. The all-in-one machines were the hardest to clean with steam tanks that require regular maintenance and some areas you can't see much less reach for proper cleaning. The Baby Brezza Complete has a lot of parts and the unique blade with small holes required rinsing immediately after use, or you'd be scrubbing for awhile to get the holes clean.

Depending on the product you choose  making baby food can be easy enough for a child to do (with proper supervision of course)!
Depending on the product you choose, making baby food can be easy enough for a child to do (with proper supervision of course)!

Conclusion


Buying a baby food maker can be a challenging decision if you have little experience in this arena. Deciding if you need an all-in-one machine or a simple puree device alone can be difficult, add on determining just how you plan to use the maker and what is most important to you and the decision can become overwhelming. After extensive testing, we think there is an option here for every family with almost any baby food making goal in mind. If you're looking for more advice on how to make your decision, you'll want to review our buying advice article to help you determine if you need a cooker/blender or if a simple puree machine will do.
Juliet Spurrier, MD & Wendy Schmitz

  • Share this article:
 

Follow Us

Unbiased.

You Might Also Like